For example, texture packs (should you use them), well, all of the categories.

So, let's start off with a couple projects. I'll just pick out random ones and 1 or 2 "What's hot" and popular but some random. And, some famous on other sites but are on PMC not famous on here.

Ok, so into the projects.

Explodable Creeper Statue 3D art

Download/View here: http://www.planetminecraft.com/project/explodable-creeper-statue/

I picked this one random. Well, first off, 3D art. It's really boring and you should only view it by the thumbnail.
For 3D art, you should put scenery. This one has none. It's only a level 1, so we shouldn't go hard, but look at all the higher levels posting this. I like how you can explode the TnT, but thats it. It's basically the thumbnail that is the project. 3D art should have background images, or detail, like using lime wool and stuff to shade it, just like a skin.
So I'd overall give this a 7/10 due to the fact it's a level 1, but if it wasn't it would be 4/10. Don't post that. It's got no reason, and only gets around 20 views. Also, improve from THEIR mistakes, rather than making your own.

Next project, lets get a whats hot one.


Israel style M.B.T Keine (4:1) Page: http://www.planetminecraft.com/project/israel-style-mbt-keine/

This type of stuff without downloads, they should take 2 minutes to make a zip/rar download. Putting that negative to the side, let's look at the thumbnails. Luckily it has many. Thumbnail one, actually looks quite good. Thats probably +1 or 2 points already,
Thumbnail 2 and 3 are the same and they look like a standard thumbnail, -0 points.
Thumbnail 4, looks unique, I really like it.

Ok, thumbnail 5. You can really see it uses too much normal cobble. It needs more mossy, it's not meant to look symmetrical and beautiful. It has evidence it's meant to be fierce. Final thumbnail, you can see the wheels look great. I'd give this 8/10.

Thats the reviews for projects for now, let's move onto skins.

Christmas Duck View/Use: http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/christmas-duck-3676709/

first off, it has no bottoms. But it's ok, it's s duck an animal, it's not inappropriate.

It has no shading what so ever. This is a bad example. And, I can't belive they have it as 100% complete?!?!?!?! Like, that's not complete. Next review. PS: 1/10 cause they tried

oops (I dont know the title) http://www.planetminecraft.com/skin/oops-3676769/

Obviously this is an accidental Re-Upload, but it's the popular one. Ok, so.
It has a bit of shading, thats a start.
It has wonderful use of jacket etc 1.8 feature. I love it.
9.99/10
JOKING! 11/10 ign.

Thats it that I got for now, post your reviews in the comments!