I like both, but I voted for Sophie because her shading is a little more detailed, and the colors look nicer.

Told you, your gonna win xD

I've never seen either of your skins before so I guess I can give a fairly unbiased opinion. It is quite difficult because they are too different kinds of skins. Sophie has went for the traditional realistic shading however FireStar (awesome name by the way) seems to have gone with the simple yet recognizable style.

I'm going to go with Sophie for personal preference but may sub both of you anyway.