Bon voyant que tu es français je me permet de te le dire en français :D.mais franchement tu peux être fier de ce bateau car pour trois choses: la première est le forme de la coque et des voiles qui est très réussi ensuite l'effet un peut usé de ton bateau est très intéressant et donne l'effet d'un bateau abbandoné ,la dernier point est le dégradé les couleurs sur ton bateau son très bien géré que ce soit pour les différentes sortes de bois et la pierre enfin bref pour résumer :j'adore :D

Like it but I feel like I've seen somehing like this recently. Anyway nice, main critique I have is a more organic hull towards the bow.

Very nice, maybe add some interior screenshots?

Very nice. As stated down below, the pictures do need to be clearer. I recommend using Chunky to render it and you'll get very nice crisp pictures. You can do lots of things with Chunky once you get the hang of it and learn different camera angles and stuff. If you want, I can render a quick picture of it and post the link here.

Cool, the most accurate of this one is probably the bow, well done.. but it's said to see you havn't made an interior, especially when there is plenty of footage of the interior from the movies, and also some more details, like rigging would not hurt, sails are attached to nothing and so on..

Looks nice...diamond for you mate ;)